July 12, 2010
Not Medically Necessary and Other Nonsense
On Thursday, I got a call from the surgery center where I'll be having surgery next week. They told me what my co-pay would be and everything seemed to be good to go.
On Friday, things changed.
It took one call from my doctor to reduce to me to a crazy lady who didn't know if she wanted to scream, cry, hit someone, crawl into a dark hole, or all of the above.
My insurance denied the surgery claim.
The plan for next week is that the plastic surgeon is going to open me up, remove the screw in my tibia, clean up the mess that is inside my leg, attach a piece of alloderm (commonly used for breast reconstruction surgery to attach implants to actual human tissue), cut out the nasty scar I have now, and close me up from the inside out.
The insurance has said this is "not medically necessary" and that alloderm is only approved for use in the "breast." They're also saying this surgery is "experimental," to which I'd like to say "Of course it is, you morons, because how many people have the 'common' problem of having a screw back out of their bone, complicated by the fact that they have no tissue in that area which means that the skin is basically indented and transparent. Oh, and it bruises and bleeds a lot. The screw also cuts me from the inside out if I happen to graze it on anything, even lightly."
So, in the world of medicine, where it takes almost two months to get a surgery scheduled and even longer to get an actual physician to call you back, I need two letters of medical necessity from a plastic surgeon and my orthopedic surgeon, by like Tuesday (as in tomorrow). As if that's going to happen.
To say that I am frustrated would be an understatement of universal proportions.
Because I knew I wasn't going to be able to handle speaking to anyone about anything regarding this, Mr. BBM took over and called the insurance company and my plastic surgeon's office.I tackled the office of my ortho guy and the lady on the other end of the phone from me made the mistake of saying "Humph, well I can't guarantee that he can have a letter for you." Yeah, because it's SO hard for a physician to dictate a letter and have someone type and fax it.
She was about ready to hang up the phone, when I reiterated that my ortho guy said he would do whatever I needed him to do so I can get this taken care of and that he, himself, had offered to write a letter for me. I told her that I didn't wait until the last minute to ask him. The insurance waited until the last minute to deny the claim, not even two weeks before surgery. This isn't my fault and I clearly need some help. She repeated her line and I had an internal debate about whether or not me telling her off would expedite the process or not. Instead, I opted to tell her that the screw is soon going to come out of my leg on its own if it's not fixed. I also gave her the visual of it cutting me from the inside out. I'm hoping that will motivate her to be a bit more helpful. My gut tells me it won't.
In the medical profession, people are just so used to saying the word "no" that it seems they say it without even considering the desperate person on the other end of the phone. Mr. BBM tells me I am having this surgery whether it's approved or not, and that we'll spend our lifetimes fighting the charges if necessary. I just wish something about this whole knee business would be easy, just once.
I’m sorry you’re going through this.
I’ve come to the conclusion that, since the reform bill was passed, insurance companies are finding all kinds of reasons to deny coverage for things. We were just denied coverage for a pair of orthotics for Lil’ M when he has been wearing similar ones for his entire life (and this same insurance company has paid for them the entire time).
Oh man, that is miserable. I had that issue with my surgery – almost six months of preparation, only to find out that the insurance company wouldn’t cover it. We changed providers and I had to wait another six months, but I felt so depressed about it.
You’ll get it done, and you’ll finally start to feel good about that part of yourself again. Promise.
Ugh. SO sorry. What a pain. It took my mom several years to get her hysterectomy covered, during which she hemorrhaged on and off. I don’t think she ever really recovered from the last year of waiting for the surgery.
And even worse, my cousin worked for an HMO, which wouldn’t pay for her medically necessary hysterectomy, because it wasn’t a life or death situation. They said that since it wasn’t KILLING her, they wouldn’t pay. She needed a transfusion of several units of blood, or she would have died. That’s when they finally said they’d pay. For their own employee. Who worked in the OB department of the hospital/HMO.
This was quite a few years ago, and had absolutely nothing to do with recent legislation. Insurance companies have been pulling this crap for many years. I haven’t seen any evidence that the legislation will change that in the least.
BBM, I’m really sorry you’re dealing with this crap. Where health is a concern, you shouldn’t have to worry about this stuff.
I’m in complete agreement with “J”. Insurance companies have and always will be about profit first. If it’s a choice between saving a few bucks or doing the right thing, they are for-profit organizations first and foremost.
Personally, and you can call me a socialist if you want, but if we had a single payer system, none of this would be a concern.
So frustrating! I hope you find your way through the appeal process too.
I’m holding you to that promise!
The problem seems to be that people behind desks are making medical decisions when those decisions should be up to the doctors who are treating patients. It’s SO frustrating!!! You’re nothing but a number or a piece of paper to them.
Thanks Steve. I just think we should get back to the days when doctors actually gave a crap and knew their patients personally. Why should I have to fight with a secretary about getting a letter written? That made me more mad than anything and if the doctor had sent the letter in the first place, this wouldn’t be an issue. SO frustrating.
I’m sorry you have to deal with this. I can kind of relate. Not too long ago, my daughter was diagnosed with a serious and chronic condition that requires expensive treatment. Not surprisingly, the insurance was a major pain. I’m usually calm about these things but one day, after I’d been on the phone for over an hour and spoke to so many people and departments that I literally had no idea who I speaking to anymore, I broke down and started crying. I’d just had enough. (I think insurance companies COUNT on us giving up.) Thankfully, the lady on the other end took pity on me and offered to help. Anyway, I really hope this gets straightened out.
I had similar issues with my breast reconstruction, believe it or not – and that was almost five years ago, so it isn’t the health care reform bill that screws thing up, that’s for sure. I think it is more along the lines of the suits at HMO Central – not a medical degree amongst them – deciding what is and isn’t medically necessary. And far too often, it comes down to what it will cost them, unfortunately. I too, got stuck two weeks before surgery with a major denial after everything was a go. It finally worked itself out – rather, I got pissed, wrote a lot of letters and called a lot of people and it went like it was supposed to in the first place. They suck, bottom line!
I’m sorry you are dealing with this, I really am. All the best with your insurance company. And I hope it is resolved, like, yesterday, BBM…
As a person who has worked various medical jobs, I absolutely despise people who work like phantom doctors…that is: because they read protocol in a book and have never, ever studied medicine Yet think the book gives them the “power”!! And, unfortunately, good people end up being hurt or waiting for things that are, by all logic, and standard of care medically necessary. I have seen it time and again and it.fucking.pisses.me.off.
I see it in the hospital ER’s with the JCAH standards and some of the protocols contradict each other and then docs get sued. If you just let the doctors do what they were trained to fucking do, it would be a whole lot better.
If anyone here thinks that new health care bill will make it all better, I can write a blog post that will astound you. Don’t kid yourselves. Now, today, you get to fight to the end to be your own advocate. After the new bill, wherein you begin paying for four years *before* you reap the benefits, you will not have any say and those lackeys will be in charge of all of it.
Sorry for the mini rant…hope you got the letter you needed, BBM. If not, I would be happy to open up a can o’ whoopass for you…