April 27, 2009
Making It Work In The Dark
I had to drag myself to the dojo tonight. I spent most of the day outside in temperatures that were around 90 degrees, working on my yard and gardens. What else is new? By the time I had finished eating dinner, I was ready for a nap. Instead, I dragged myself to the car and arrived at a sweltering hot dojo.
Our dojo is not one of those strip-mall places with central air. There's nothing fancy or high-tech about it. We have window air conditioners that sometimes cool things off (or not). Mostly not. We have flooring that bubbles up when it's hot. When the temperatures rise in there, on the second floor, it's definitely unpleasant.
One of the most important lessons I've learned from my dad is this one: hot air rises, cool air sinks. So, I sunk onto the floor and did my stretches in a horizontal position. I don't tolerate heat well and when you stack that on top of the exhaustion I already had, I was pretty miserable.
I tied my hair up on the top of my head and the four of us in attendance, decided that the lights were staying off. We didn't need anything else heating things up. At first we could see just fine, but as the night wore on, the darkness was as heavy as the heat. It was the perfect time to build up to having a night time attacker.
Without being able to see facial expressions, and only being able to see a shadow coming at you, it felt realistic. I sometimes have a hard time following through on techniques and let people out of things before I probably should. But I didn't tonight. Each of the two guys I worked with saw the ground a bunch of times and I was proud of how I responded and what I did. It wasn't always pretty and things didn't always work the way I wanted them to, but I found myself trying to work several techniques instead of just trying one that doesn't work and giving up.
The darkness added a veil of scariness to the whole drill. You wanted to finish your opponent. The other woman and I each took a turn with each of the guys, and then we took turns attacking each other too. It was a very realistic drill that taught you something about yourself. It starts out being something you think will wreck your confidence, and then you find out it's done just the opposite.
After class, I was talking to the other woman in the locker room about the drill. We were discussing the issue of self-defense. As a woman, people tend to side with you if you're attacked and you happen to take out your attacker. But what if you're a trained martial artist, you're attacked, and you break some bones or cause other serious damage? Then what? What exactly is a woman allowed to do to defend herself in the world and how does that change when that woman just happens to be a high ranking martial artist?
It's an interesting question and it made me think about a conversation I had with one of the builder guys the other day. He was fixing something on the exterior of my house and I was planting some flowers. He noticed I was kneeling funny and asked me about my knee. I told him about my surgery and he asked me how I had injured myself.
"Karate. I was sparring at the time" I told him.
He asked me how long I have been training and what rank I was. I told him my next rank testing will be for Shodan and he asked me with complete seriousness, "So, when you get your black belt, you'll have to go get your hands registered with law enforcement right?"
I laughed out loud. I think he was a little embarrassed, so I contained my laughter and told him I had heard something about that somewhere (Where did I read that anyway?), but that I didn't think I was required to do that upon getting a black belt. Am I wrong? I guess I always thought that was a joke.
It does raise an interesting question though. If a man attacked a woman on the street, and she (a trained martial artist) fought back and broke an arm, ripped a ligament, poked out an eye, and sent the family jewels packing? Would she be in trouble?
Personally, I think the guy is asking for it if he's a stranger on the street and he grabs me. Of course, there's the issue of appropriate force; but when it comes to it being a stranger on the street? I'm not taking any chances. It's my life we're talking about here.
What would you do if attacked on the street by a complete stranger? How would you feel as a juror, on a case where an attacked woman beat the living daylights out of her attacker or even killed him? These are interesting questions and I'm going to do some research of my own and see what I can come up with on this topic.
If you find out the legalities of it, let me know. It’s something I’ve always seriously wondered.
In the UK it’s certainly a gray area. I think the best advice is “hit them once, put them down but don’t follow up”. After that it becomes unreasonable force. Personally anyone that gets a good beating after attacking someone gets just what they deserve and should have no recourse in law. But then that’s just me!
The law depends on the state. In some states, if a reasonable person would fear for their life, you can respond with force that is up to and including deadly force. In other states, your response has to be proportionate to the danger you were in. Personally, if I was on a jury and a man attacked a woman and she beat the absolute shit out of him and left him for dead, I would find that to be justified on her part in almost every situation.
Black Belt magazine had a series of articles on this very subject not that long ago. It was very interesting. I don’t remember alot of detail except that each state has its own laws regarding martial artists defending themselves. Worth a search for the articles though.
If a man attacks a woman and she beats the crap out of him I’d say he got what he deserved. I’m not sure how his attorney might spin the events.
One of my sociology profs told a story about walking with two women, in Europe somewhere, when one of them came up missing — a guy had pulled her into an alley. When the prof and the other woman noticed and backtracked a couple of steps they stood by and watched as she kicked the stuffing out of him… the gal he’d grabbed was a martial arts instructor. (This story was told in 1980, so it likely happened in the mid 70’s.)
That’s such a great question, BBM. I’ve heard about registering, too, but am not sure if it’s a myth or not. Time to do some research! Personally, if attacked, I would put them down so that they could not get back up. Why risk it? I’m sure a jury would see it that way, too. Of course there’s excessive force, but it’s definitely a grey area when it comes to that. We learn these techniques so that we can defend ourselves. Of course it’s so much more than that, but it’s an important aspect of our training. I say beat as much crap out of them as you can so that they cannot chase you when you run away.
I’m fairly certain that there is no “hand weapon” registry anywhere, but it can’t hurt to look.
As to the attack thing, you are allow to defend yourself regardless. In my state you are allowed to shoot someone if you feel threatened, so I can’t see how you would be unable to defend yourself simply because you are capable of defending yourself.
Most of the guys at my dojo are police officers and my Sensei is a police corporal (this is Florida, could be different elsewhere) – he talks about this A LOT. Now, with the way he puts it I keep thinking – I would never do that, he must be talking to the guys (as in Bar Fight) but… it really depends. If some comes at you with a knife and you get it out of his hands and proceed to break his neck, call the cops, and say – oh, he attacked me, see, a knife – and have not a scratch on you – its not going to hold water. Defend yourself to the point by which you can escape – but once you break the barrier (rage, for instance) and use unessecary, aggressive force – as in, the guy is down and helpless yet you continue to wail on him – you could get arrested yourself. Now, I’ve never been in a rage, I can’t see myself beating the tar out of someone (though my Sensei says it kind of takes you over & you don’t remember it later) – but what if you Accidentally kill/maim someone? In any case, people are going to ask questions, but if all things point to it being self defense you’ll be fine – just don’t Kill a guy whose just trying to snatch your purse.
As for being a registered weapon, he’s never mentioned it, I think its urban myth. Though, as police officers, the black belts in my dojo certainly can’t react with deadly force w/o facing inquiry. I do know that you have to have a weapon’s permit to carry nunchaku in our state. My Sensei teaches us to drive when carrying nunchaku with them out on the seat beside us so that no police officer can say we’re carrying a weapon. You do need a concealed weapon’s permit to carry them on your person.
I think in general you just use common sense but, honestly, if I’m ever attacked, I doubt I’ll be thinking “I wonder if I’ll get arrested for this?”
Ah – I found a thread with the (a?) Black Belt Magazine article in question. http://www.kajukenbocafe.com/smf/index.php?action=printpage%3Btopic=4857.0
OH, yeah, I can get you registered with the police, sure. No problem. Send me $79.99 and I’ll get your name registered in book form at the US Patent office and you’ll get a certificate with your name and coordinates and ….
Oh wait, that’s for star registration.
One of my fellow students who tested for his Black Belt with me asked the same question. My instructor, a 6th Dan, knew of no such legitimate registration anywhere.
Thanks for the link to the articles that reinforce this.
You do not have to register yourself as a lethal weapon. That’s BS and a cultural fiction.
You DO have to consider getting sued if you lay the smackdown on someone. Even a mugger.
Once thing I learned from my 4 years in corrections is that inmates will sue. So will criminals on the street.
You should check out Patrick Parker’s latest post and maybe contact Loren Christensen. I’m sure he could tell you what is what.