March 22, 2007
I’m being too nice
Since Monday I’ve been working on my first kata, Nai Hanchi Shodan, every chance I get. I figured that if I’m going to go kata by kata and start fixing things, I might as well incorporate bunkai (application) into my practice as well.
Mr. BBM has been a great help to me with this and has been a fabulous uke. He has continued to stay a good sport, even when I demand that he come over and punch towards my face within minutes of him walking in the door from work, so that I can block and throw him around a bit. He didn’t even mind that much when I was experimenting with joint locks and completely wrenched his arm unintentionally while I was deep in thought.
The problem in working with him though is that when you’re first trying to work out the application, it goes very slowly. Slow kata means that you forget where you are in the kata as you go. So, I keep having to start from scratch, figure out where I’m at and then continue on. If he knew the kata he would be of greater assistance to me-yet another reason he needs to get his butt back to the dojo.
I’d been thinking about the bunkai for this kata all day today and when he walked in the door tonight from work I had to try it out. Instead of using a double block and back fist as simply a block against a punch, block against another punch, followed by a back fist to the head, I wanted to change it up a bit. I blocked his first punch, and then pulled the other arm up underneath and around his arm I just blocked, and then back across centerline so as to twist his arm up behind his back. Basic bunkai is cool enough, but finding a move in there that you didn’t know was there is even more exciting.
When I got to class tonight, I asked my instructor how one would do the back fist after that arm lock without it being awkward. So, we started off class with a basic bunkai demonstration for the first kata, followed by a not-so-basic demonstration that was really cool.
The other cool thing is that right as class was beginning, a black belt walked in, which meant he got to play the role of uke (i.e. person who gets thrown around), not me. Bonus.
When all was said and done and both demonstrations/explanations were finished I came to the conclusion that I am being entirely too nice to Mr. BBM. Kosa steps are not simply steps; they can be kicking the leg out from underneath someone. Bringing one’s hands back to an on guard position on the belt isn’t preparing for the next attacker; it can be breaking an attacker’s neck. I was shocked at how many kills there were in that kata and am now seeing it in a whole new light.
I think Mr. BBM will be seeing me in a whole new light after I try some of those moves on him too, like possibly the light that he’ll be staring up into when he’s found himself flat on his back with no warning(rubs hands together and evil laugh ensues).
Now I want to see you do the kata and see how it compares to our Naihanchi.
Then I want to learn all the cool bunkai!
I just love learning the deadly applications of kata. I’ve just started learning the bunkai for Pinan Sandan. I don’t know if you do this kata but the part where you turn and look like you’re pulling up your pants, is really grabbing your attackers pants and flipping them on their backs. heh heh heh (now I am rubbing my hands together and laughing evilly) I love that stuff!!!
be easy on the guy!
😀
kudos to him for being such a sport
It’s like Mr. BBM is Kato to your Clouseau.
PB: Maybe someday I’ll be brave and post a video of me doing a kata. I just hate myself on film so much that it’s unlikely that even if I do it, it would see the light of day, much less air time on the ole blog.
Frotoe: Me too! I love seeing all the cool stuff in the kata’s. Pinan Sandan is my worst kata. I am not a fan, but that part you’re talking about is cool. It looks so funny when you’re doing it (Big I always laughs at me), but the bunkai is very neat.
Mat: yep. He is a good sport. I’m lucky.
Karl: ha, ha, great analogy.
Hey, I’ve tagged you. Check out details at my blog. Do it if you like.
Ooh, be careful with the uninitiated. We wouldn’t want to “really” hurt them or anything! I wonder what Big I and C think when their parents spar!
Mr BBM seems to be taking your practicing on him in stride. My husband wasn’t so willing!
The kosa steps (kosa-dachi) also work well as traps for uke’s legs. It’s great that you’re finding different interpretations for bunkai. As you’re finding out, there’s a huge difference between exploring kata’s applications and just running through a form. The bunkai is what it’s all about.