April 26, 2006
Forget Mommy Wars; I’ve got a new cause
"Mommy Wars" have been popping up everywhere lately. Here, here, and here are just a few of the people who are talking about it. If you don’t feel like clicking on all of the links, I’ll just summarize for you. They’re mostly saying let’s stop talking about it because frankly, it’s getting pretty old. Amalah had a virtual fist fight going in her comments section the other day about them. You can even go here to find a link to a petition to call a cease fire in the Mommy Wars. (Go sign, but come right back.)
The problem seems to be simple, at least for the Mommy Wars in the blogging world. For the most part, working Mom’s who get upset and offended are reading into what Stay at Home Mom’s are saying and vice versa. Of course, there are some really rude people out there; but the majority of women out there mean no one else any harm by what they say. I’m going to say one last thing about it, and then I’m moving on. If you are a mother, repeat after me: Whatever I choose to do with my life in regards to my children is my business and mine alone.
Every mother will always think that her decision is the best and wisest one. There will even be some who try to push their views on other people. There are MANY who will read or hear something completely neutral; and because they have made the opposite choice and are feeling insecure about their decision, will feel the need to berate a perfectly well-meaning person who meant absolutely nothing derogatory in her statement. This, unfortunately, is what a lot of women do. This is the reason why for the longest time my best friends were always guys. They lack the catty gene. It’s a good thing. I am NOT a catty person; and I don’t really get along with people who are. My female friends whom I hold near and dear are very much like me when it comes to the whole anti-cattiness thing (if that’s even a word.)
So, I’d like to declare a new war. . . one that all mothers: working at home, stay at home, working out of the home can agree on and relate to completely. It is the cause to unite all mothers under one collective motherly roof. . . against those who believe that all baby girls are born with braids, and all baby boys are born with buzz cuts. Let me explain.
The other day I took my daughters out to a store with me. Lil C, who is 6 months old, was wearing: a short sleeved lavender silk sweater, white boot cut pants with little purple flowers on them, and a white lacy bib. As I was checking out, an older woman came over and started talking to Lil C. Our conversation went like this:
Older woman: "A boy, huh?" (and nods in Lil C’s direction.)
Me: (Sighs disgustedly and forcibly looks at Lil C’s extremely GIRLY outfit and then at woman. Thinks in head, "Yeah, because everyone I know dresses little boys in lace bibs and purple flowers. Also, silk is the new denim, and by the way, you’re an idiot," but actually I say. . . ) Girl (with a terse eye roll).
Older woman: (as if she’s offended) "Well, where’s its hair?"
Me: (Thinks in head, "Yeah, because every female baby I know is born with freaking pony tails LADY, and actually THIS BABY is not an IT!!!!!!!! She is my beautiful baby girl and she has PLENTY of hair." But what I actually do is. . .) Glare at woman and walk away.
The same thing happened when Big I was about Lil C’s age. We were in a grocery store. She was wearing a pale yellow sun-suit with pink and purple flowers on it. An older lady said, "A boy?" and I had to restrain myself. It seriously gets under my skin. Why are all babies boys? I mean, I know that some people (o.k., I admit it, I) always call dogs or cats by one gender in particular. But that’s a whole lot less obvious. It’s not polite to look between the legs of anything, including a dog or cat; and it doesn’t count because animals don’t wear clothing (unless of course, we’re talking about Paris Hilton’s dog and then it’s probably pretty obvious what the gender is anyway). Later that night I told my husband what happened and how annoyed I was. He had a good solution for me. It goes something like this:
Older woman: "A boy, huh?"
Me: "Girl, sir."
It goes like this if the offender is male:
Man: "A boy, huh?"
Me: "Girl, ma’am."
I am so using this next time. So, this brilliant husband of mine goes along to karate tonight. We were working on sparring. I was working with my instructor and Big I was working with a 9-year old girl who has a very unisex haircut. To his credit, she also had a helmet on at the time; and he wasn’t present during the beginning of class when this girl was talking a lot, obviously a girl. As Big I stood there refusing to make a move, my husband encouraged her by saying, "Go ahead; punch, hit, you won’t hurt him." The girls mother was sitting next to him and offered a simple, "Her." Now, I can’t blame my husband here. Anyone could have make this mistake.
But with a baby, it’s a lot easier to tell. Even when you can’t, there are easy ways to find out. When I’ve been in a situation where you just simply can’t tell, I’ll say something like, "Aww, how old is your baby?" The mother will usually respond with, "He’s 6 months old," or "She’s 6 months old." The door is now wide open for you to say, "Well, she’s adorable." You didn’t know, but you found out without making the mother want to drop you in the aisle at Wal-Mart.
Here are some other clues that the baby you’re inquiring about just might be a girl:
- She’s wearing pink or lavender.
- She’s wearing a floral bib that says, "Thank Heaven for Little Girls" (Seriously, I had someone ask me if she was a boy while wearing this bib.)
- There is lace on any part of her body: socks, bib, hat, etc.
- She’s wearing a swimsuit, not trunks. Honesty, I had someone ask me if Lil C was a boy while wearing this:
It has a ruffle PEOPLE! A RUFFLE! There’s another one:
- Boys don’t wear ruffles. If the baby has a ruffle on socks, pants, shirt, swimsuit, dress. . . the baby is a girl.
- It may seem obvious, but if the baby is wearing a dress, the baby is a GIRL!!!!
So, are you with me Mommy’s? I’m sure it is equally annoying when someone identifies a baby boy as a girl. So, let’s all bond together with a common disgust for those who cannot tell the gender of our babies, against those who refuse to find out in any polite sort of way. Mommy Wars are exhausting: this whole gender war thing could be a whole lot more fun!
Well – I remember a while ago an older chap had come up behind me in a store and said ‘Excuse me Miss’ to get passed. He got a bit of a shock when I turned around and he discovered I had a beard!! (Admitedly I did have very long hair then!)
But we’ve had this problem, especially with the little one as it seemed to be ages before her hair suddenly appeared over night!!
Everyone thinks our girl is a boy. Everyone. maybe because we dress her in bluejeans and red thermal tops or olive green rock n roll tees? But funny enough, when she’s in pink people say, “she’s just SO girly! How could anyone mistake her for a boy?” We’ve gotten used to it I guess.
But i have learned that if she isn’t in head to toe pink…like god forbid there’s a little grey in there or even some denim, she’s a boy to the world.
What I can’t believe is how rude people are to you about it! Like they’re personally offended by the fact that she has no Y chromosome. I think your reponse is just perfect.
(And hey, thanks for the blogroll shout out. So nice of you!)
Mommy Wars are one of the most silly things ever. It’s a waste of time. I understand people have values that they uphold and that’s fine, but please don’t push them on other people. Women do what is best for their families and themselves. And that’s that. Have a little respect.
Many people think Keenan is a girl. He has longish blond hair and long eyelashes. But that’s it. He is always dressed in blues and greens or something really boyish. And his haircut is really boyish, too.
Your Lil C is definitely a girl. Some babies you can just tell by looking at their little faces. The light in their eyes is a little different. Maybe I’m weird, but it just seems like girls and boys have a different energy 🙂
Yes, the aggravating dumbasses of the world. We need to band together to wipe them all out. I love the recommendation your husband gave.
I’ve refused to post about the mommy wars. I agree with you-personal decisions are no one’s business but your own, so just SHUT-UP!
Here I thought I was the only one with this problem. The dear petite little Blossom, her hair just hasn’t grown out yet and is short across the back of the neck as well. The Branch, on the other hand, is big and burly and has lots of hair. I’ve had people ask me if he was a girl! (Despite clothes with numbers and sports themes on them). I even had them both at the pharmacy counter, where Branch has numerous prescriptions in his name. The pharmacist, normally a sharp guy who never, ever screws up our orders, looked at the Blossom and said “Is this the Branch?”. And the Blossom was wearing something with pink in it.
After having my own kids, I have realized why the stereotype pink, hearts and flowers for girls and blue, sports themes and numbers for boys clothing exists. It’s for the benefit of other people. Not your kids.
I don’t criticise mothers who work even though I stay at home. I realize I am fortunate to be “able” to stay at home and not “have” to work. Others aren’t that fortunate and don’t have a choice.
Actually in Florida it is everybody’s business what you do with your kid. The government is very nosy down here. You really have to watch your Ps and Qs in public.
I have several thoughts on this…first, Maya was mistaken for a boy when wearing a PINK DRESS WITH FLOWERS on it. Sigh.
I was mistaken for a boy quite often, and my brother, who had red curls, was a very pretty little girl, thank you very much.
I’m anti-Mommy wars, but I almost changed my mind today when my cousin told me that she spanked her daughter last night until her hand hurt, and THEN SWITCHED HANDS. I told her that I thought that was excessive, and she said, it wasn’t enough.
Now, I’m anti spanking, but I also know that many people are NOT anti spanking, so I keep my mouth shut, mostly. But does that seem like abuse to anyone? Seemed a bit much to me.
It’s too much stereotyping here about the hair. I’ve had pple coming up to me to say that Gavin is a girl. Many times. Even now!!! And then they’ll ask me why is his hair so short? *rolls eyes*
Okay, he may have long eye lashes, but he has short hair, wears obviously boys clothes. I’m more drama…I will say things like OMG, he’s a boy…can’t you see. Boy’s clothes, boy’s shoes? OMG. Just to embarrass the other person, especially if I’m in the mood.
Which is why I will ask if I’m not certain of a baby’s gender. I try not to guess but if I accidentally make a wrong guess then I’ll apologise for it.
My theory has always been that if the family is happy, the child/children is/are happy…then who am I to say how they’re to raise their children? I only intervene if the child has a consistent history of hurting my own child and the parent has a consistent history of ignoring/excusing it or- even worse- thinking its funny. And by ‘intervene’ I mean ‘stop getting together with’.
But yes! The gender thing! My daughter *had* enough hair for those teensy little look-like-cindy-lou-who pigtails, and people *still* assumed she was a boy. Even if I had her in a pink frilly dress with black mary janes. I could have had a sign on her that said ‘GIRL’ in huge letters and I think they’d still make the mistake. I swear some people just categorize babies as male…kinda like how my in-laws ALWAYS call dogs ‘he’ regardless of gender. Even if they *know* the gender.
It does seem to be fairly one-way, I have to say. My son is now 17 months old and he has NEVER been mistaken for a girl.
I personally never, ever assume ‘boy’ when I see a baby in jeans & a t-shirt (something we dressed my daughter in quite often). There are just so darn many ways to find out! Really!
My son is 16 months old. Since the day he was born, he’s been repeatedly mistaken for a girl! He can be wearing a blue jumper with monster trucks on it and he’ll still be mistaken for a girl (this actually happened)!
For a while, my husband blamed it on the fact that I refused to cut Snuggle Bug’s hair until he was a year old. He has the most beautiful curly blond hair and I cried the day it got cut.
Even after the haircut, he continues to be mistaken for a girl. I don’t know how many times I’ve been told, after correcting someone, “He’s too pretty to be a boy!”
Ugh! What is with people! He’s going to have a complex when he’s older if this keeps up.